Better than most MMO anniversary crap. Hell all you get in wow is some fireworks and a dumb ass looking pet. The rez pots always come in handy, advancement pots always come in handy. As to the cloaks, guess I'm a vanity *****, I do wear them with my toons.
Aside from that, they are still working on getting the crafting update etc. done. I dunno, I think you guys are being a little harsh here. Personally I can't stomach the majority of crap MMO's out on the market, and really they don't have to do a damned thing for anyone on thier aniversary. It seems to me you guys are trying to shut them down at this point.
As to the free access passes for FtP, is that really a big deal? It is only temperary and not perm passes.